We're updating the issue view to help you get more done. 

Defer literal map construction of syntax-quoted maps to allow for semantically valid unquote splicing


At present one cannot unquote-splice into a map literal unless the map contains an even number of literal forms, even if one of them is a null unquote (~@[]).

E.g.: `{~@[1 2]} ;=> RuntimeException Map literal must contain an even number of forms clojure.lang.Util.runtimeException (Util.java:219)

However, within the context of a syntax-quote, it is not essential that the map literal be represented internally as a map since the syntax-quote emits code to build the map and not the map itself. The syntaxQuote method on SyntaxQuoteReader does not even operate the map, but rather a flattened sequence of interleaved keys and values.

With the aid of metadata and a LispReader-global Var, we can track that a collection of elements within a syntax quote will become a map, and emit the proper code forms from the SyntaxQuoteReader. There is a small edge case in metadata literals, but an with additional piece of metadata containing the proto-map we can still generate the appropriate (with-meta ...) form at syntax-quote emission time.

Importantly, none of the hand-waving involved ever escapes the reader, and the eval/compile environment is none the wiser.

This allows the following:

`{~@[1 2]} ;=> after eval: {1 2}
`^{~@[:foo :bar]} sym ;=> metadata of 'sym after eval: {:foo :bar}

But not:
`~{1} ;=> RuntimeException ...

{1} ;=> RuntimeException ...

And `{@[1]} has the same semantics as the currently required `{@[1] ~@[]}
;=> IllegalArgumentException No value supplied for key: 1 clojure.lang.PersistentHashMap.create (PersistentHashMap.java:77)

The changes in my patch pass all existing tests and include an additional test for the newly-supported map unquote-splicing form.







Jon Distad





Code and Test

Affects versions

Release 1.7